How it works
Three steps. No card to carry, nothing to scan, nothing to remember. No membership number and no password. Just sign in with your email and we'll send you a code.
Points post automatically on every order. You earn for creating your account and celebrating your birthday too.
Pick a reward, get a code, apply at checkout. Engraving, gift wrap, glassware and more.
Every order counts toward your tier. Higher tiers earn more and open earlier allocated windows.
Engraving & greeting card rewards
After you redeem an engraving or greeting card, enter the message on that item in your cart or at checkout. Pay Now stays closed until it is saved.
Verified reviews
Trusted by collectors, one bottle at a time.
Every rating below comes from Judge.me, updated automatically, so you see what real customers say.
- 5★716 reviews with 5 stars
- 4★2 reviews with 4 stars
- 3★0 reviews with 3 stars
- 2★0 reviews with 2 stars
- 1★2 reviews with 1 stars
Latest from verified buyers
-
Bought as a gift for a friend and he loved it! Very smooth and this is the second of the Blanton’s he’s tried and looking forward to trying the rest.
April A. Verified buyer Nov 2026
Blanton's Takara Black Edition Gift Set with Wooden Box & 2 Crystal Glasses – 750ml
-
Excellent value and service / delivery
Freddy S. Verified buyer Oct 2026Received a thank-you code
Elmer T. Lee Single Barrel Bourbon Rare Release 90 Proof 750ml
-
This tequila is my favorite but as a bonus from ordering from you is the outstanding service.
Anonymous Verified buyer Oct 2026Received a thank-you code
Fortaleza Blanco Tequila 750ml
-
It was a gift for my Husband and he really was happy to get it. It was packed very well and the container it came in is nice.
Donna L. Verified buyer Oct 2026Received a thank-you code
WhistlePig Old World Rye Whiskey 750ml Aged 12 Years
-
Excellent bourbon! Excellent price! Just an excellent all around experience! Super well packaged bottles.
Barre K. Verified buyer Sep 2026Received a thank-you code
Blanton's Special Reserve, Eagle Rare 10 Year, and Weller Special Reserve Bourbon Bundle – 700ml + 2 x 750ml
-
Excellent bourbon and service. This is my go to from now on. Thank you
Freddy S. Verified buyer Sep 2026Received a thank-you code
Elmer T. Lee Single Barrel Bourbon Rare Release 90 Proof 750ml
-
I bought this as a gift. This company offers an exceptional selection of Bourbons. Follow up from start to finish puts them in a league of their own.
Maura S. Verified buyer Sep 2026
Weller 12 Year Bourbon Gift Set with Glencairn Glass 750ml
-
Excellent condition, my orders are always as promised.
Kenneth A. Verified buyer Sep 2026Received a thank-you code
Buffalo Trace Antique Collection Double Eagle Very Rare 20 Year Bourbon Whiskey 750ml
-
I purchased this as a gift from the Rare Bourbon Shop. They were very efficient and followed through to be sure I received my order. I would use them again. Great Customer Service!
Anonymous Verified buyer Sep 2026Received a thank-you code
W.L. Weller C.Y.P.B. Wheated Bourbon 95 Proof 750ml
-
I was very impressed with the different options to choose from and the quality of service received. I’m about to make another purchase.
Andrew F. Verified buyer Sep 2026Received a thank-you code
Best Sellers Trio – Blanton's Original, E.H. Taylor Small Batch & Eagle Rare 10 Year – 3 x 750ml
-
This bourbon is the best. I don't drink bourbon straight as it is too strong for me. This is a wonderful sipper that is smooth and tasty. This was a first time purchase (but not the last) with this vendor. The...
Anonymous Verified buyer Sep 2026Received a thank-you code
W.L. Weller Antique 107 Wheated Bourbon 107 Proof 750ml
-
Superb bourbon!! Customer service was outstanding! Above and beyond. Thank you.
Tom A. Verified buyer Aug 2026Received a thank-you code
Blanton’s Gold Edition U.S. Release Rare Bourbon 103 Proof 750ml
Showing the latest 4★ and up reviews from verified buyers. The overall rating includes all 720 reviews. See every review
Review rewards
Review your order. We'll say thanks.
Leave an honest store review after delivery and we'll send a $20 Reserve Club credit.
Write a review
Search a bottle to review, or write a store review.
Or write a store review
One reward per customer per month. Any honest star rating qualifies.
Good to know
- What can I actually redeem?
- Whatever the program currently offers — the live list, with the point level for each one, is above. Rewards can change, and what is shown there is always the current set.
- How do points get added?
- Automatically, once your order is paid. Nothing to scan, nothing to submit. If an order is cancelled or refunded, the points that came with it come back off.
- Where do I see my balance?
- On this page when you are signed in, and any time from the Rewards tab on the edge of the screen.
- How do I redeem?
- Choose a reward from the list above. You will get a code to apply to your cart, and the reward's own terms and expiry are shown before you use it.
- Do rewards expire?
- Every reward carries its own terms, and they are shown with the reward before you redeem it. Your balance is always on this page.
- What does it cost to join?
- Nothing to buy. Creating your account unlocks earning starting with your very next order.
There is no cost to join. Reward availability and shipping vary by state. Must be 21+ to purchase. Please drink responsibly. Void where prohibited. Rare Bourbon Shop may adjust the program at any time — the earn rates, reward levels and balances shown on this page are read live from the program, so what you see here is what is in effect.